Boeing Is Pro-Growth, Not Anti-Union

Washington's actions have assaulted the capitalist principles that have sustained America's competitiveness since it became the world's largest economy nearly 140 years ago. Full Story »

Posted by Kelly Garrett - via Real Clear Politics, Wall Street Journal (Opinion), AllTop, Wall Street Journal (Most Emailed)

See All Reviews »

Review

Kelly Garrett
3.5
by Kelly Garrett - May. 11, 2011

A carefully written criticism of the NLRB's conclusion that Boeing acted unlawfully when it decided to build a new plant in South Carolina after failing to reach an agreement with union leadership in Washington state. Some of the claims are obviously one-sided, some of the views expressed are extreme, and anger seems to bubble through at time, none of which is surprising given that the author is the CEO of Boeing. Nevertheless, the letter clearly conveys Boeing's position, and provides ample opportunity for a thoughtful response.

The NLRB is wrong and has far overreached its authority. Its action is a fundamental assault on the capitalist principles that have sustained America’s competitiveness since it became the world’s largest economy nearly 140 years ago.

One of the more extreme claims.

Important to our case is the basic fact that no existing work is being transferred to South Carolina, and not a single union member in Washington has been adversely affected by this decision. In fact, we’ve since added more than 2,000 union jobs there, and the hiring continues.

See All Reviews »

Kelly's Rating

Overall
3.5

Good
from 10 answers
Quality
3.4
Facts
3.0
Style
4.0
Balance
2.0
Expertise
2.0
Relevance
4.0
Popularity
4.0
Recommendation
4.0
Credibility
4.0
More How our ratings work »