The Sidney Awards

Every year, I give out Sidney Awards to the best magazine essays of the year. In an age of zipless, electronic media, the idea is to celebrate (and provide online links to) long-form articles that have narrative drive and social impact. The first Full Story »

Posted by Jo Bobenhouse Smith - via Fair Spin (Right), Opinion Source, New York Times (Most Emailed), New York Times (Opinion)

See All Reviews »

Review

Jo Bobenhouse Smith
4.3
by Jo Bobenhouse Smith - Dec. 29, 2009

A writer on writing: David Brooks gives us his take on the best of 2009.

So David Rohde does not get a Sidney for his unforgettable series on being held captive by the Taliban. But those pieces possess exactly the virtues that the Sidneys are meant to honor, and they make one proud to be a journalist.

I try not to give Sidneys to the same people year after year, but the fact is, talent is not randomly distributed. Some people, like Matt Labash of The Weekly Standard, just know how to write. His piece, “A Rake’s Progress” was a sympathetic and gripping profile of Marion Barry, the former Washington, D.C., mayor, crack-smoker and recent girlfriend-stalker.

See All Reviews »

Jo's Rating

Overall
4.3

Good
from 9 answers
Quality
4.3
Information
4.0
Insight
4.0
Style
5.0
Popularity
4.5
Recommendation
5.0
Credibility
4.0
More How our ratings work »