Another 'black man did it' hoax sparks outrage

It's an old lie, claiming that The Black Man Did It.

But it was trotted out again last week when a white mother from suburban Philadelphia said two black men snatched her and her 9-year-old daughter from their SUV and abducted them in the trunk of a black Cadillac. Full Story »

Posted by Michael Bugeja

See All Reviews »

Review

Joel Kulenkamp
4.5
by Joel Kulenkamp - Jun. 6, 2009

This shows a very disturbing pattern

Talk about deja vu all over agian!

The Black Man Did It lie last made news as recently as October, when a John McCain volunteer claimed a 6-foot-4 black man carved a B into her cheek (For Barack, evidently). Charles Stuart told it in 1989 after he killed his wife in Boston. Susan Smith told it when she drowned her sons in 1994 in South Carolina. Unknown numbers of black men were hanged for it back when lynching was a common practice. “Here we go again,” thought Add Seymour, an Atlanta resident who works in public relations for Morehouse College.

One easy explanation is that black men are convicted of crimes at much higher rates than any other group. So was falling for Sweeten’s lie racism, or common sense? And does Sweeten’s blond hair have anything to do with the amount of media coverage her story received?

New York Times columnist Bob Herbert recently wrote about the difference in coverage between the killing of a white female college student in Connecticut and the approximately three dozen Chicago public school students, mostly black, who have been killed this school year. He recalled an incident from early in his career, at another newspaper, when he heard an editor pondering the story of a dead child ask, “What color is that baby?”

“Editors may not be asking, `What color is that victim?’ But, on some level, they’re still thinking it,” Herbert wrote.

See All Reviews »

Joel's Rating

Overall
4.5

Very good
from 13 answers
Quality
4.5
Facts
4.0
Fairness
4.0
Sourcing
5.0
Style
5.0
Context
5.0
Depth
4.0
Enterprise
5.0
Relevance
4.0
Popularity
4.5
Recommendation
5.0
Credibility
4.0
More How our ratings work »