Holbrooke of South Asia

America's regional envoy says Pakistan's tribal areas are the problem.

His face tense and unsmiling, a young man from a village in Pakistan's western tribal areas tells his story, mixing English, Pashto and Urdu. He is the only male in his clan to get an education, but can't find a job, and blames a corrupt national government. Americans are bombing his neighbors, he says, tempting him to join the Islamist militants in his area. Across the room, another Pakistani turns toward his hosts at the U.S. Embassy and says, "You are ... Full Story »

Posted by Fabrice Florin

See All Reviews »

Review

Fabrice Florin
3.8
by Fabrice Florin - Apr. 11, 2009

Informative behind-the-scenes report on Richard Holbrooke, the new American special representative for Pakistan and Afghanistan. The reporter follows him in a series meetings with people from tribal areas, as well as U.S. and Pakistani military commanders. Factual, enterprising and very insightful.

Mr. Holbrooke asks a dozen or so men in the room about the presence of the Taliban in their villages. “We are all Taliban,” comes a response. The others nod in accord. All are or were “religious students,” or Taliban in Pashto. But the expression of solidarity with the various Pakistani and Afghan insurgents who go by the name is lost on no one.

Observations by Matthew Kaminski.

See All Reviews »

Fabrice's Rating

Overall
3.8

Good
from 12 answers
Quality
3.8
Facts
4.0
Fairness
4.0
Sourcing
3.0
Style
4.0
Context
4.0
Depth
3.0
Enterprise
4.0
Relevance
4.0
Popularity
4.0
Recommendation
4.0
Credibility
4.0
More How our ratings work »