Does the threat from al Qaeda justify a major escalation in Central Asia?

The Afpak muddle (part 2)

Does the threat of international terrorism -- specifically al Qaeda -- justify a costly, long-term engagement in Afghanistan and Pakistan? President Obama and his advisors think so, but I'm still not convinced. I certainly understand that we have a terrorism problem; I just don't believe that it is serious enough to warrant the level and type of effort the administration is proposing. And if the results of the recent NATO summit are any indication, our ... Full Story »

Posted by Kaizar Campwala

See All Reviews »

Review

Kaizar Campwala
4.0
by Kaizar Campwala - Apr. 10, 2009

Asks some important questions about America's costly involvement in Central/South Asia. I like how he give counter-arguments, which don't appear to be straw man arguments (see linked responses from Democracy Arsenal and Obsidian Wing)

In America, the danger of drowning in a bathtub is greater than the risk of dying in a terrorist attack. And that would be true even if the United State were to suffer one 9/11-scale attack every ten years. Given these numbers, does it really make sense to double down in Central Asia?

What we need, in fact, is a political elite (and a responsible media) that will help Americans keep the terrorism problem in perspective. Terrorism is a tactic that various groups have used throughout history, and it will remain with us for the foreseeable future. Dramatic incidents like the recent Mumbai attacks are going to happen again, no matter how hard we try to prevent them, and that includes the possibility of attacks on American soil. But if we can keep suicidal extremists from obtaining nuclear weapons, they will not be able to threaten our way of life in any meaningful way.

See All Reviews »

Kaizar's Rating

Overall
4.0

Good
from 13 answers
Quality
3.9
Information
3.0
Insight
5.0
Style
4.0
Context
3.0
Expertise
2.0
Originality
5.0
Relevance
4.0
Responsibility
5.0
Popularity
4.5
Recommendation
4.0
Credibility
5.0
More How our ratings work »