Harvard Medical School in Ethics Quandary
A group of Harvard Medical School students and faculty are intent on curtailing industry influence in their classrooms. Full Story »
Posted by Julian FriedlandA group of Harvard Medical School students and faculty are intent on curtailing industry influence in their classrooms. Full Story »
Posted by Julian FriedlandA solid report on the role and influence of pharmaceutical money in the nation's best medical schools.
As a student-journalist at another university in Boston, I looked at whether money from defense contractors like Lockheed Martin had affected academics and campus. This is an important issue.
Great investigative reporting about a serious matter. The author has gone out of his way to research factual evidence from multiple sources, with helpful context about apparent conflicts of interests at Harvard Medical School.
What are the drawbacks of industry ties? This article lets a lot of people weigh in on the ethics of accepting industry money without fully explaining the consequences of doing so.
clearly the issue presented here is both topical in relationship to our health care system reform and ethics-related. as such it merits greater discussion than is in this article. bravo to the medical students who notice this and bring it to the schools' attention so that the larger discussion and resolution can take place within them.
An informative article, and it could be much more in depth. The featured statistics hint at the tip of what appears to be a very large iceberg of conflicts of interest between some Harvard med school doctors and the pharmaceutical industry.
This brief investigative article exposes: medical educators with close ties to the pharmaceutical industries (and how it is discouraged in the classroom discussion of side effects of some drugs and perhaps even other alternatives), but at the same time the writer exposes the benefits of having these pharmaceutical because they fund research. Though the writer, Duff Wilson, exposes both sides in a fair manner, Wilson goes back to his thesis, nutgraf, which is the fact that there is a dangerous problem when our health is on the hands of special interest groups. I think the story could have been improved by adding more examples of where there are special interest groups running health interest (ex: government agencies, advocacy ... More »
Shame on the brightest who have not questioned this behavior. Not only medical schools, but also public schools that receive funds or material for education with product advertisements such as milk, candies, and fast food should be questioned. Also political positions such as FDA should be question: Who are the people running these companies? What ties do they have with the industries they monitor? It is probably a common factor in all types of industries to have people with vested ... More »
’The Harvard students have already secured a requirement that all professors and lecturers disclose their industry ties in class — a blanket policy that has been ... More »
First rate investigation from Duff Wilson. Very important and at the center of so much contention in the highest reaches of power. Could have ferreted out some industry responses though, or at least mentioned that they declined to comment if they were asked. Still, it does a good job seeking balance by interviewing at least one pro-industry funding professor.
Lots of opinions about the relationship between drug companies and medical education, but not many facts.
The report is substantial and excellent, especially considering how complex (far-reaching, with many aspects) the phenomenon of money bias in healthcare is, and how concise the article is.
The report should at least mention something essential for the public to realize: that this topic is closely related to many other equally thorny (or insidious?) topics - such as subtly tainted research, inappropriate health insurance coverage, money bias in choosing research topics, "slow medicine" rather than pulling out all the stops for the very elderly or frail, and a dozen others. No one topic can be analyzed fairly, or worked on successfully, without at least keeping an eye ... More »