FactChecking ‘The Pledge’

Republicans' "Pledge to America" falls short on some of its facts.

The Republican “Pledge to America,” released Sept. 23, contains some dubious factual claims. It declares that “the only parts of the economy expanding are government and our national debt.” Not true. So far this year government employment has declined slightly, while private sector employment has increased by 763,000 jobs. It says that ... Full Story »

Posted by Donica Mensing - via NewsRack (Politics), FactCheck, JR Russ (t), David K. Miller (t), Fabrice Florin (t), Steven K Samra (f), Fabrice Florin (f)
Tags Help
Member Tags: 2010 Midterm Elections, barack obama, pledge to america, small business, articles, economy, unemployment
Editorial Help
Mike LaBonte
4.4
by Mike LaBonte - Sep. 25, 2010

The documentation is excellent as usual, and FactCheck remains neutral.

See Full Review » (11 answers)
Jack Dinkmeyer
4.2
by Jack Dinkmeyer - Sep. 25, 2010

As usual FactCheck does an excellent job analyzing propaganda masquerading as policy. It’s all there: objectivity, evidence backing up the analysis, and a liberal use of quotes and links.

If right wingers really believe in their “pledge,” God help us, everyone. Because what right wingers have come up with is proof positive the inmates have taken over the asylum.

See Full Review » (20 answers)
Sirajul Islam
4.3
by Sirajul Islam - Sep. 27, 2010

an excellent piece of journalism, well-researched, well-linked and well-referenced. The storywriter's, as well as FactChecks' point is well taken by this: 'The GOP is certainly entitled to state those opinions, and it’s not our role to argue for or against them. Nor is it our job to say whether the promises laid out in the document would be good policy or bad policy. That will be debated elsewhere for the remainder of the campaign. Our role here, as always, is to say when facts cited to support the arguments are false or misleading.'

See Full Review » (19 answers)
Donica Mensing
4.2
by Donica Mensing - Sep. 27, 2010

This article reviews the facts cited in the Republican's "Pledge to America" to identify which are based on evidence and which are exaggerations or dishonest statements. Holding politicians accountable for their statements is one way to help our political discourse align a little more closely with reality.

See Full Review » (11 answers)
Katie Boswell
4.4
by Katie Boswell - Sep. 26, 2010

Insightful exposé of the inaccuracies in the Republicans' "Pledge to America".

Many of the claims are true. But as might be expected in a partisan manifesto, this is a lopsided rendering. At times it is more caricature than portrait: any facts that ... More »

See Full Review » (20 answers)
Chris Finnie
4.7
by Chris Finnie - Sep. 26, 2010

I love this stuff! I hear so much rhetoric any more that it's refreshing to know what of it is true, and what false. This fulfills the most basic requirement of journalism--to inform the electorate.

See Full Review » (11 answers)
Randy Morrow
3.5
by Randy Morrow - Sep. 25, 2010

But as might be expected in a partisan manifesto, this is a lopsided rendering. At times it is more caricature than portrait: any facts that might brighten it are simply ... More »

See Full Review » (11 answers)
Preston Watts
by Preston Watts - Sep. 25, 2010

No. Any post, article, opinion, or editorial that has an action represented in it's title needs to adhere it's principal . FactChecking ‘The Pledge’ would require the piece to report on the "facts". Any statements that are put forth to judge fact over fiction that contain, yes but , true but, is a misrepresentation It's true, Not only reduce the quality of the work to 0 but is insulting to anyone with an IQ of over about 80.

Although "The Pledge" is misleading in total it's "facts" are by far and away superior to that of FactChecks".

See Full Review » (2 answers)
Henry M. Green
4.0
by Henry M. Green - Sep. 26, 2010

Fact checking is one of the most essential forms of journalism no amateur blog will ever be able to replace

See Full Review » (9 answers)
Cristian King
4.0
by Cristian King - Sep. 24, 2010

This was a very well written piece that was extensive and well researched. It was factual and well sourced, having extensive amount of statistics from government websites and previous articles published. It was fair in that, although the article was clearly critical of the Republican "Pledge to America", it did give that the statements they had given were not 100% untrue. The article was extensively went through each point of 'dubious factual claims'. It was definitely relevant because with so much information floating around these days about the economy and what the parties are saying, its good to get a third party perspective. Overall it was a very good read, well written, and definitely opens the table for conversation about ... More »

See Full Review » (11 answers)
Chris Sloan
4.0
by Chris Sloan - Oct. 31, 2010

The article links to the actual source document for the pledge. Their facts are based on actual government data, and respectable financial news sources like market watch.

See Full Review » (3 answers)

Comments on this story Help (BETA)

NT Rating | My Rating

Ratings

4.3

Good
from 18 reviews (49% confidence)
Quality
4.3
Facts
4.5
Fairness
4.2
Information
4.0
Insight
4.0
Sourcing
4.5
Style
3.9
Accuracy
4.0
Balance
4.0
Context
3.9
Depth
4.1
Enterprise
4.1
Expertise
4.3
Originality
4.0
Relevance
4.5
Transparency
4.3
Responsibility
4.0
Popularity
4.4
Recommendation
4.4
Credibility
4.4
# Reviews
5.0
# Views
5.0
# Likes
1.0
# Emails
2.0
More
How our ratings work »
(See these related stories.)

Links Help

  • The GOP's bad idea

    (Blog Post) "America is more than a country," begins the GOP's 'Pledge to America.' America, it turns out, is an "idea," an "inspiration," and a "belief." And the GOP wants to govern it. ...
    Posted by Barry Grossheim