Move the New York City mosque, as a sign of unity

The national debate about building a mosque near Ground Zero in New York is less about our freedom of religion than about the common sense and uncommon courtesy sometimes required to come together as Americans. In our society, we are free to do many things that we nonetheless choose not to. During my lifetime, a number of racial and ethnic slurs have been effectively banned from our national vocabulary -- not because our free speech has been limited, but ... Full Story »

Posted by Jon Mitchell - via Real Clear Politics, Memeorandum, Google News (Religion), Washington Post , Umbreen Bhatti (t), Salvador Sala (t), David Fox (f)

See All Reviews »

Review

Jack Dinkmeyer
1.9
by Jack Dinkmeyer - Aug. 21, 2010

Definitely a right wing op-ed in which me thinks she doth protest too much. Her contention is putting an Islamic cultural center that includes a mosque close to hallowed ground represents a hostile act because: “It goes to the heart of who is to blame for the attacks on September 11, 2001.” Clearly implying all of Islam is to blame. Then she expends an ungodly amount of equivocating arguments trying to explain away her original statement. Her argument comes down to this: trying to get Muslims to get the Hell out of Dodge themselves, which involves Muslims taking the initiative: “Sometimes uncommon courtesy is required for us to get along in our free and diverse society.” My God! “Uncommon” courtesy doesn’t even come close to trumping: “...make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”

Right winger anti-mosque arguments take three forms: 1) The realtor approach–location, location, location. How dare those terrorist Muslims desecrate our hollowed ground with their version of a church! 2) We believe in freedom of religion, but C’MON! Meaning, we really do believe in freedom of religion but only for ourselves. 3) Then there’s the one in this op-ed. Muslims must do the “right thing.” Meaning, we really do believe in religious freedom, so why don’t you get us off the hook and go somewhere else on your own?

Rauf and his congregation are certainly free to locate their mosque near Ground Zero. But I hope and pray that they will show uncommon courtesy and decide not to.

See All Reviews »

Jack's Rating

Overall
1.9

Poor
from 20 answers
Quality
1.8
Facts
1.0
Fairness
1.0
Information
3.0
Insight
1.0
Style
2.0
Accuracy
1.0
Balance
1.0
Context
1.0
Depth
1.0
Enterprise
1.0
Expertise
1.0
Originality
1.0
Relevance
5.0
Transparency
1.0
Responsibility
1.0
Popularity
2.5
Recommendation
1.0
Credibility
4.0
More How our ratings work »