Baucus' 'no' vote on public option draws otherwise friendly fire

Sen. Max Baucus angered many Democrats back home in Montana when he voted last week against a "public option" in the health care reform legislation working its way through the Senate Finance Committee. Full Story »

Posted by Kristin Gorski - via Google News (Lobbying)
Tags Help
Stats Help
# Tweets: 0 (as of 2009-10-04)
Editorial Help
Posted by: Posted by Kristin Gorski - Oct 4, 2009 - 4:20 AM PDT
Content Type: Article
Edit Lock: This story can be edited
Edited by: Derek Hawkins - Oct 5, 2009 - 7:32 AM PDT
Derek Hawkins
3.7
by Derek Hawkins - Oct. 6, 2009

The Tribune went to a range of sources to give us an impression of whether Baucus is publicly hedging on the public health insurance option. Mostly state-level, this was an interesting, insightful and well balanced report.

Eric Feaver is president of MEA-MFT, the state’s largest labor union. He said he sees little evidence that Baucus ... More »

See Full Review » (11 answers)
Kristin Gorski
3.7
by Kristin Gorski - Oct. 5, 2009

An interesting angle is reported here from a local Montana newspaper. If anyone has wondered what Senator Max Baucus, Finance Committee Chair, has been thinking regarding a health care reform bill, this article has some answers. While short on statistics and facts, it is a worthwhile analysis, nevertheless.

“Health care reform is a 10-act play, and you do not write a review of the play until you see the end of all the acts,” Sabato said. “We don’t know ... More »

See Full Review » (20 answers)
Patricia Blochowiak
2.3
by Patricia Blochowiak - Oct. 5, 2009

The story can be summarized thus: "Baucus says that he supports the public option, but those who really support the public option think he doesn't." Not much of a story.

See Full Review » (18 answers)
Jo Bobenhouse Smith
3.8
by Jo Bobenhouse Smith - Oct. 5, 2009

This is a local Montana-specific story with an unfortuneate title. The closing paragraphs with comments from locally know politicians should be at the beginning of the story. I would have lead with Sabato's analogy and used it in the title. Sabato: "Health care reform is a 10-act play, and you do not write a review of the play until you see the end of all the acts," Sabato said. "We don't know what's going on behind the scenes. (Democrats) do have a plan for a bill, and they have a plan for how they're going to get this done, but we won't know what that is until it's done."

See Full Review » (4 answers)
Diane Kamp
4.6
by Diane Kamp - Oct. 6, 2009

John Adams is a quality reporter who has often taken on the powers in Montana. I would have liked Adams to talk to one more source outside the Democratic Party machine in the state. The head of the labor union, Feaver, was a good source. One more Baucus skeptic might have given a little more balance to the conventional wisdom of Bergren, Elliott and Sabato. The idea that the people of Montana will forget what happened in the Finance Committee is also conventional wisdom that may not work this time around. But it is what Baucus is counting on.

See Full Review » (6 answers)
Susan Eleuterio
4.7
by Susan Eleuterio - Oct. 6, 2009

This is one of the few stories I've seen that offers details on the maneuvering against the public option by Democrats and the response by supporters of the public option. Most stories just take politicians like Baucus at their word, this one offers some specific criticism of his actual behavior.

See Full Review » (4 answers)
Toni Zimmer
3.5
by Toni Zimmer - Oct. 6, 2009

I believe John Adams did a great job of presenting the different sides to this story while staying on topic throughout. The reader is left to draw his/her own conclusion regarding Senator Baucus' longterm intentions and the public option. Well done.

See Full Review » (5 answers)

Comments on this story Help (BETA)

NT Rating | My Rating

Ratings

3.6

Good
from 8 reviews (50% confidence)
Quality
3.6
Facts
3.9
Fairness
4.0
Information
2.0
Insight
3.5
Sourcing
3.4
Style
3.3
Accuracy
3.5
Balance
3.5
Context
3.3
Depth
2.7
Enterprise
3.0
Expertise
2.5
Originality
2.5
Relevance
4.3
Transparency
2.5
Responsibility
3.0
Popularity
3.6
Recommendation
3.8
Credibility
4.5
# Reviews
4.0
# Views
5.0
# Likes
1.0
# Emails
1.0
More
How our ratings work »
(See these related stories.)

Links Help

  • Reid, Baucus ready to split on public option as vote nears

    Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) and Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus (D-Mont.), once in polite disagreement over the idea of a public option component in ...
    Posted by Derek Hawkins
  • Obama quietly tries to shore up Senate support for public option

    The president has backed off from vocally supporting the idea of government-run healthcare, but he's quietly building a coalition of supporters. The challenge: Find a version ...
    Posted by Kristin Gorski
  • Key Democrats Still On the Fence About Reform

    At least two Democrats on the Senate Finance Committee have refused to pledge support for the health-care reform bill scheduled for a vote this week, underscoring the hard ...
    Posted by Cynthia Gilbert
  • Healthcare tests Obama’s grasp of Capitol Hill game

    If President Obama’s efforts to reform the US healthcare system were judged Olympic-style – like, say, diving or gymnastics – his score would have to factor in the ...
    Posted by Derek Hawkins