An Exchange on Elitism

I value executive skill more than most conservatives do I think. Some NRO readers seem to imagine it's just a matter of having the right convictions and sticking by them. I think it is way more complicated than that....I am not denying that Sarah Palin may have great skills. She may well. I am insisting that neither you, nor I, nor John McCain has any valid reason to believe that she does. Full Story »

Posted by Beth Wellington

See All Reviews »

Review

Beth Wellington
4.4
by Beth Wellington - Oct. 1, 2008

This is an interesting piece, because Frum, a Republican speechwriter, asks his fellow party members and conservatives to seek information on Palin, rather than to accept her nomination blindly. Frum is a writer on the right I admire. Whether you agree with him or not, he provides insight and writes clearly. This piece is especially balanced because it is a dialog consisting of his response, interspersed w. a letter from his reader Eric Hosemann, who supports Palin. And because, while he now suports Bush, he raises questions about what his relative lack of experience meant to the country: "George W. Bush had very slight executive experience before becoming president. His views were not well known. He won the nomination exactly in the same way that Palin has won the hearts of so many conservatives: by sending cultural cues to convince them that he was one of them, understood them, sympathized with them. So that made everything else irrelevant in 2000 - as it seems again to be doing in 2008. I do credit George W. Bush with great feats of leadership. In particular, I think his refusal to quit Iraq in 2005-2006 when everybody was urging him to, his insistence on fighting through to success, will be seen as a triumph of strength and conviction that saved the US from potential disaster. But he lacked other important aspects of leadership which is how we got into the mess from which he needed to rescue the country and himself. "

See All Reviews »

Beth's Rating

Overall
4.4

Good
from 11 answers
Quality
4.6
Fairness
4.0
Information
4.0
Style
5.0
Accuracy
4.0
Balance
4.0
Context
5.0
Popularity
3.5
Recommendation
4.0
Credibility
3.0
More How our ratings work »