Author Amy Harmon fails to point out the falsehoods and flaws in David Campbell's teaching. E.g. the Mickey Mouse analogy better fits a creation/designer scenario than evolution; his moth-picking activity perpetuates a long-discredited fraud (the peppered moth evolution story - in which birds were filmed pecking dead moths off trees they had been glued to); and his comments about fossils are wrong (see "Karl Kruszelnicki: still missing the missing links"). The author assumes the evolutionary story is true and the creation story false, neglecting to point out that both are worldviews based on axioms (unprovable assumptions), and neglecting to challenge the dogmas of the evolutionary view. However, Harmon does succeed in presenting a graphic portait of the indoctrination many students face in school. Andrew Lamb