Elegy For A Rubber Stamp

Long ago in the days before journalists became celebrities, their enterprise was reviled and poorly paid, and it was understood by working newspapermen that the presence of more than two people at their funeral could be taken as a sign that they had disgraced the profession.

Full pdf here:
www.nationinstitute.org/pdf/Elegy_for_a_Rubber_Stamp.pdf Full Story »

Posted by Julian Friedland

See All Reviews »

Review

Floss Shahbegian
5.0
by Floss Shahbegian - Oct. 1, 2008

It was not only a very good article but a very rewarding one as well. The entire funeral proceeding actually lasted beyond 3 days. It went on in the TV News programs for 2 weeks. It was repeated with exaltation about Russert's greatness as a journalist. For me it was an amazing show since I never considered Russert to be a journalist. His weekly standard of reading his guests previous quotes, his inability to really conduct an intelligent dialog was appalling & annoying. The news media have positioned themselves as celebrities to be exalted much as the second rate Hollywood celebrities. Their coverage of a mediocre journalist was astounding. Consider the short shrift they give to people who have made major contributions to the world. Especially those whose accomplishments were done before some of these news people were adults. So their lack of knowledge of the accomplishments of important individuals is appalling. We are so fortunate to have Lewis Lapham demonstrate such courage and intelligence to write this eminently excellent article.

(comment refers to full article)

Nothing missing and needs no improvement. It is excellent.

See All Reviews »

Floss's Rating

Overall
5.0

Very good
from 14 answers
Quality
5.0
Facts
5.0
Fairness
5.0
Information
5.0
Sourcing
5.0
Style
5.0
Accuracy
5.0
Balance
4.0
Context
5.0
Popularity
5.0
Recommendation
5.0
Credibility
5.0
More How our ratings work »