Jindal Excites GOP As a Possible Running Mate

Louisiana Governor Of Indian Descent Has Youth and Zeal

Before Sen. John McCain could begin speaking at a town-hall meeting here Wednesday, he first had to quiet a crowd gone wild for Republican Gov. Bobby Jindal -- a politician who not long ago would have been inconceivable in Louisiana. Full Story »

Posted by Beth Wellington

See All Reviews »

Review

Max Blum
2.2
by Max Blum - Oct. 1, 2008

Goodness! "The similarities between... Gov. Jindal and Illinois Sen. Barack Obama are tantalizing to many in the Grand Old Party." Like what, how, says who? There's a nagging whiff implied in this article that the Republicans, in a deficient, racially tinged imitation of the Democrats, may have found their version of a "dark skinned" person to add to their ticket in an attempt to stay competitive with the Democrats. A word of advise to the writers: I would be more careful next time addressing this type point. The line is at best idiotic and irresponsible, because it just sits there, without explanation, a proper analogy, or factual corroboration. With respect to McCain: the writers, being US press, all institutionally and terminally sympathetic to Arizona pol., must of course inject lines that sound more like a transcription of a press release from the Republican's campaign organization rather than journalism: "Gov. Jindal has succeeded in the state at gaining the backing of social conservatives and pro-business fiscal hawks, while appealing to moderate suburbanites -- the formula many Republicans believe Sen. McCain must achieve to win the presidency." Nice. Who are the "many Republicans"? How did Jindal succeed in doing what these authors claim here? Where are the FACTS to back up this? The least us readers can expect from one of the "premier" newspapers in the world is for its journalists to show some professional effort.

“…a tacit admission that the Bush administration’s bungled response to Hurricane Katrina remains a memory he must address for many Americans.” A memory!! How about a daily living disaster for hundreds of thousands two-and-a-half years later!

…a tacit admission that the Bush administration’s bungled response and recovery work after Hurricane Katrina remains an ever present issue, one McCain must continue to address throughout his campaign.

See All Reviews »

Max's Rating

Overall
2.2

Poor
from 8 answers
Quality
2.2
Fairness
2.0
Information
2.0
Sourcing
1.0
Context
3.0
Popularity
2.5
Recommendation
1.0
Credibility
4.0
More How our ratings work »