The Take: Historic win or not, Democrats could pay a price

As the final round of the battle over health-care reform begins Sunday, President Obama and the Democrats are in reach of a historic legislative achievement that has eluded presidents dating back a century. The question is at what cost. Full Story »

Posted by Kaizar Campwala - via Jay Rosen, Google News (U.S.), Slatest, Real Clear Politics, Google News (Republican Party), Jeppe Kabell (t), Donica Mensing (t), Joey Baker (t), miker1717 (t), Jason Samfield (f), Kaizar Campwala (f), Dave Palmer (f)

See All Reviews »

Review

William Owney
2.4
by William Owney - Mar. 21, 2010

Like so much political discourse these days, this piece uses one piece of unexamined narrative to produce another, and so on. As Kurt Vonnegut once remarked, if things were different, other things would be different, too. This piece begins with the COW that HCR reform is overwhelmingly unpopular with the public and is being passed despite their wishes. That assertion has been well litigated elsewhere and found to be less than convincing. It is much more salient as a journalist to challenge the conventional wisdom and ask what price the right pays if it continues to debate an issue when the public is ready to move on? That would have been a good Sunday think piece.

More on point at this stage, when passage is assured, is how the public will come to view a president who put his personal prestige on the line for something in which he deeply believed? It is much more reasonable to believe that Obama's approval ratings will turn upwards, as will those of his party as the elections near. If the right continues to negatively harp on this issue in the summer and fall, what will be historic will be its inability to gain seats in an off-year election.

See All Reviews »

William's Rating

Overall
2.4

Poor
from 12 answers
Quality
2.1
Facts
2.0
Fairness
2.0
Sourcing
2.0
Style
2.0
Context
2.0
Depth
2.0
Enterprise
3.0
Relevance
2.0
Popularity
3.5
Recommendation
2.0
Credibility
5.0
More How our ratings work »