Sally Lehrman

Member (since February 2009)
Help
Hosting Immigration Help

I teach journalism courses and also maintain my work as an independent journalist covering science and social issues for a variety of print, Web and broadcast outlets.

About Sally Help
Location: California, United States
Occupation: Knight Ridder Chair in Journalism in the Public Interest, Santa Clara University
Expertise: Science and society; race and gender issues; inclusive coverage
Affiliations: Society of Professional Journalists American Society of Journalists and Authors National Writers Union Media Workers Guild Online News Association
Host  (Sally hosts these topics) Help
Topics: Immigration
Background Help
Journalism: More than 20 years
Education: College graduate
News: 90 minutes a day or more
Internet: 90 minutes a day or more
Contact Info Help
Web Page: www.bestwrit.com
Address: CA, US
Last Visit: Feb 7, 2012 - 5:37 PM PST
Last Edit: Jan 7, 2011 - 2:46 PM PST

This profile can be seen by everyone, including search engines. Help

Activity

Show all | Reviews | Posts | Starred | Comments
Sally commented on this review – Jan. 22, 2012
Holly Hanbury-Brown
3.1
(NT Rating: 3.1)
Reviewed by Holly Hanbury-Brown - Jan. 19, 2012

This article provides an interesting way into the tensions between Palestinian Arabs and Jewish Israelis by getting at the issue on a personal level, through the likeable character of Charka. It gives us an opportunity to look at these issues not just in terms of the extremists, but in terms of the average citizen who really desires peace. On one hand this is good journalism because it brings a relevant issue to light in a way that people can connect to on a personal level. However, there are a couple of grammatical errors that make the article lose credibility for me, such as the sentence "The settlement are sitting on top of a giant bomb." This is not a bad example of adaptation to online journalism, because it has an image ... More »

Sally Lehrman Comment:

Thoughtful response, and good use of evidence to back up your claims.

Sally commented on this review – Jan. 22, 2012
Lucia Gonzalez
3.3
(NT Rating: 3.2)
Reviewed by Lucia Gonzalez - Jan. 18, 2012

Of the eight characteristics that Ryan Thornburg identifies in his book, "Producing Online News Digital Skills, Stronger Stories," the most relevant ones to this article are magnitude, conflict and novelty. Google, commonly referred to as a "web giant" is a site visited by millions of people across the globe on a daily basis, therefore the demographic affected by the integration of Google+ with the search engine function is large. Novelty and conflict are interrelated in this story. Social media networking is still its primitive stages of development, it is an "unusual subject" as Thornburg describes it in his book. The novelty of the subject matter, inevitably creates areas of dispute and as social media continues to unfold, ... More »

Sally Lehrman Comment:

Lucia,
You offer great evidence for your claims, although some may argue that social media isn’t really new anymore because use is so extensive. Do you think the NYT used the best medium to tell the story, as outlined by our current Thornburg reading?

Sally posted this story - Jan 22, 2012
Sally posted this story - Jan 22, 2012
Sally commented on this review – Jan. 16, 2012
Sam Gisi
3.2
(NT Rating: 3.7)
Reviewed by Sam Gisi - Jan. 17, 2012

This article frames health as a medical responsibility because the author explains how doctors are helping people survive cancer. Also, the quote from Dr. Tom Frieden helps supports my statement by saying that doctors cannot cure everything, but they cure as much as they can. The article can be frame differently in showing how cancer can be prevented thus focusing more on personal or societal responsibility. The author could have also spent more time on explain why each number is the way it is instead of listing a lot of facts with no support behind it.

Sally Lehrman Comment:

This review does not answer the question posed for the group.

Sally commented on this review – Jan. 16, 2012
Jordan Kahawai
3.3
(NT Rating: 3.4)
Reviewed by Jordan Kahawai - Jan. 17, 2012

This article frames health as a medical responsibility because it provides information about a medical problem called "metabolic syndrome" that the United States and people around the world face today. "Fifty million people are believed to have the metabolic syndrome, according to the American Heart Association - and that's just in the U.S." However, this article doesn't seem to come to an answer for this "metabolic syndrome" or why Americans aren't eating this way. This article could be framed differently into a societal responsibility by exploring why individuals with bad health aren't eating this way based on the community they live in, their race, and their social status. Food deserts are common in low income communities ... More »

Sally Lehrman Comment:

Good suggestion of a way to shape this article taking a societal approach. Your argument that the piece is medical in focus is too vague, though. Just because the article is about medical problems doesn’t mean that it is presenting the solution as medical as well.

Sally commented on this review – Jan. 16, 2012
Mariah Adcox
4.0
(NT Rating: 3.8)
Reviewed by Mariah Adcox - Jan. 16, 2012

This article frames health as a societal responsibility. I make this claim primarily based on the fact that the article discusses why people in the U.S. have a higher instance of bipolar disorder, not because of their genetic makeup, but because of the cultural instances that may cause this statistic. For example, the author suggests that there is a negative stigma associated with this disorder in many countries, whereas American society is acutely aware of psychiatric disorders, and much more comfortable talking about them. However, it is important to keep in mind the dangers of attributing health trends to cultural differences, as Paul Farmer points out in his book Infections and Inequalities: The Modern Plagues. Both medical ... More »

Sally Lehrman Comment:

Good analysis and support for your perspective. The genetic basis for bipolar disorder is uncertain, and the societal frame does shed new light on mental health disorders.

Sally posted this story - Jan 16, 2012
Sally posted this story - Jan 16, 2012
Sally posted this story - Jan 16, 2012
Sally posted this story - Jan 16, 2012
Sally posted this story - Jan 16, 2012
Sally posted this story - Jan 16, 2012
Sally posted this story - Jan 10, 2012
Sally posted this story - May 22, 2011
Sally posted this story - May 22, 2011
Sally posted this story - May 22, 2011
Sally posted this story - May 19, 2011
Sally posted this story - Apr 26, 2011
Sally posted this story - Apr 17, 2011
Sally posted this story - Apr 17, 2011
Sally posted this story - Apr 17, 2011
Sally posted this story - Apr 7, 2011
Sally posted this story - Apr 7, 2011
Sally posted this story - Mar 28, 2011
Sally posted this story - Mar 28, 2011
Sally posted this story - Mar 28, 2011
Sally posted this story - Feb 5, 2011
Sally posted this story - Feb 5, 2011
Sally posted this story - Feb 5, 2011
Sally reviewed this story - Jan 22, 2011
Sally's Rating
3.1

High-quality journalism does not require a "new scandal" in order to be relevant. It's true that the stories did not get much legs, but in part the blame rests on other news outlets that did not take the information and build on it. I do agree that we all must work harder to show concrete impact. And we must keep in mind that major stories can overwhelm -- they can seem too big, broad and perhaps too depressing to keep a reader's attention. We need to work harder to connect the ... More »

See Full Review » (11 answers)
NT Rating: 2.5 | See All NT Reviews »
Sally posted this story - Jan 10, 2011
Sally posted and reviewed this story - Jan 9, 2011
Sally's Rating
3.0

This is an interesting science story but correlation is not the same as causation. The reporter should have given us more context about the research methodology and the researchers' credentials in this area so that readers could better evaluate their claims. An interpretation by others in the field would also have helped. The topic is an important one, so deserves better treatment. In addition, the photo on the Reuters page is offensive. Why do stories about obese people always feature a photo shot from the rear?

See Full Review » (11 answers)
NT Rating: 3.2 | See All NT Reviews »
Sally posted and reviewed this story - Jan 8, 2011
Sally's Rating
4.6

Herbert makes the U.S. income divide concrete with a great example and sets both Congress's opening session and the latest White House appointments in a context worth considering.

See Full Review » (6 answers)
NT Rating: 4.0 | See All NT Reviews »
Sally posted this story - Jan 8, 2011
Sally posted and reviewed this story - Jan 7, 2011
Sally posted and reviewed this story - Jan 7, 2011
Sally commented on this review – Nov. 23, 2010
Rebecca Solomon
3.5
(NT Rating: 3.7)
Reviewed by Rebecca Solomon - Oct. 13, 2010

When our media is saturated with advertisements and campaigns displaying only the male sex playing video games, it is easy to see why the general public would assume that the digital sport is played predominately by men. However, the hard numbers disagree. Almost half of the top earners are now female, a fact that most people probably do not appreciate. This article attempts to educate the general public and address stereotypes that have been proliferated for so long. With solid factual evidence and a rampant spokesperson in Katherine Gunn, author Michelle Castillo takes a bold step in the right, more politically correct direction.

Sally Lehrman Comment:

This review seems to be connected to the wrong story.

Sally commented on this review – Nov. 23, 2010
Jennifer Savage
4.2
(NT Rating: 4.1)
Reviewed by Jennifer Savage - Oct. 14, 2010

The "Don't Ask Don't Tell" law, activates stereotypes and encourages discrimination. The law prohibited military officials from asking a recruit's sexual orientation, but threatened to release soldiers whose homosexual orientation was exposed. What stereotypical expectations did the military hold about a homosexual person's behavior in the military? And, while Judge Phillips issued injunction against the law, the author writes that "the government is expected to appeal the injunction to the Court of Appeals...". Although she didn't state any evidence to that effect, she may have had evidence that suggested it. One could question however, whether that statement was derived from information that she received or her own ... More »

Sally Lehrman Comment:

You raise an interesting point – how does a journalist report important misperceptions that a source may have without adding new vigor to those very same misperceptions? By the way, predictable action should not be assumed to be the same as “stereotypical”.

Sally commented on this review – Nov. 23, 2010
Markeda Cottonham
3.9
(NT Rating: 3.4)
Reviewed by Markeda Cottonham - Oct. 14, 2010

This piece is good journalism because it is relevant to today. this issue of illegal immigration and the rights allotted to persons of that status is a big debate all over the country. It gets you thinking about the pros and cons of granting rights, such as higher education, to those who, legally, aren't suppose to be here. With that said it also lacks the human side of the story. Although one quote acknowledges the struggle of an illegal immigrant, it fails to show the harmful effect these new rules may have to the undocumented student themselves.

This Coverage does well to stay away from stereotypes. Although, i did find it a bit of a conflict in the continuous word choice the author decided to use when speaking of legal and illegal students. Only once did the author state that the illegal immigrants may be more or just as academically qualified than the legal student. but each time Legal students were mentioned it stated "legally and academically qualified residents". I believe this article thus activates stereotypes by ... More »

Sally Lehrman Comment:

Interesting point about the nuances of word choice and how we are affected by the terms writers use, often without much thought.

(Beta)

Levels & Stats

Member LevelHelp
4.3 avg.
4.3 avg.
Activity
3.0 avg.
Experience
5.0 avg.
Ratings
4.1 avg.
Transparency
3.2 avg.
Validation
5.0 avg.

StatsHelp
Reviews
18
Answers
135
Comments
17
Ratings Received
4
Number of Raters
3
Ratings Given
3

Sally's Widget

Add this widget to your site »