Phil Snead

Member (since December 2008)
Help

About Phil Help
Location: South Carolina, United States
Background Help
Journalism: 1-4 years
Education: Post-graduate school
News: 30-60 minutes a day
Internet: 60-90 minutes a day
Contact Info Help
Address: SC, US
Last Visit: Sep 10, 2010 - 2:02 PM PDT
Last Edit: Aug 3, 2010 - 1:59 PM PDT

This profile can be seen by everyone, including search engines. Help
| Network |

Activity

Show all | Reviews | Posts | Starred | Comments
Phil reviewed this story - Aug 3, 2010
Phil's Rating
3.2

It's good only in respect of bringing to light yet another "black" IT operation (see "John Poindexter") about which we'll never really know the truth. The article quotes a great deal of conjecture about this project, but little that's useful. For example, how will the gov't or Google VALIDATE the system? Lack of validation is how TSA became such a huge waste of money -- will this project just grow into another example of equating "lots of information" with "having an exclusive ... More »

See Full Review » (6 answers)
NT Rating: 3.7 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil reviewed and starred this story - Feb 22, 2010
Phil's Rating
4.0

Klein makes a brief commentary on the mini-resurgence of the public health care option in the W.H. and on Capitol Hill. He reminds us that the irrational politics of health care will likely defeat the advance of the public option in this case as it did before, despite its apparent popularity with the majority of U.S. voters.

“As of now, the strategy only has 20 or so supporters, and it’ll need at least another 20 or 25 to really be viable. But if it gets there, White House and ... More »

See Full Review » (8 answers)
NT Rating: 3.6 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil reviewed and starred this story - Feb 21, 2010
Phil's Rating
4.5

Quinones' series and the accompanying video presentation, illustrating the life of addiction led by one young U.S. couple, work together powerfully. The impression is indelible, and I expect the series should leave most readers quite interested in further information about black tar heroin trafficking and addiction, both south and north of the U.S.-Mexico border.

This riveting LA Times series includes a powerful and intimate video slide presentation. Sam Quinones writes in a straightforward, convincing style, about powerful "black tar" heroin marketed from Xalisco, Mexico at lowball prices to U.S. users who could otherwise be classed as typical Wal-Mart shoppers. The marketing operation emphasizes customer service and attempts to steer clear of populations and neighborhoods that might draw elevated attention from law enforcement. Quinones ... More »

See Full Review » (7 answers)
NT Rating: 4.2 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil reviewed and starred this story - Feb 20, 2010
Phil's Rating
4.4

Brooks on the inverse trends of diversification and effectiveness in cultural/governmental/financial leadership. "It is less necessary to be clubbable. It is more important to be smart and hard-working." "[A]mass[ing] technical knowledge[ . . . ] is only marginally related to the skill of being sensitive to context." Diminished social connectedness (in geographical context).

Mr. Brooks once again steps into a delightfully disputable conceptual void, with his contention that democratization/meritocratization of paths to power has correlated with increasing public disapproval and cynicism. Characteristically Brooks plunges into the nebulous in a way that leaves us all mumbling, "Is that meant to be a complete thought?" Brooks is a highly educated and well-informed commentator. His cognitive and creative grasp frequently lead his readers and listeners ... More »

“[H]ere’s the funny thing. As we’ve made our institutions more meritocratic, their public standing has plummeted. We’ve increased the diversity and talent level ... More »

See Full Review » (8 answers)
NT Rating: 3.5 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil posted this story - Feb 20, 2010
Phil reviewed this story - Feb 14, 2010
Phil's Rating
3.0

The piece exemplifies Sullivan's consistent struggle to present measured viewpoints on questions that, otherwise, frequently draw only rabid commentary. In fact the content of this commentery belongs primarily not to Sullivan but to the blogger whom he quotes and cites within the column. The argument for a variation of a "truth and reconciliation commission" as a means of discouraging a repetition of the US' disreputable conduct in the course of emasculating the nation of Iraq, is by now familiar. Clearly if it were ever going to happen ww'd have a clearer sense of that by now.

The greatest outrages of OIF will be evident in the continuing deterioration of polity in that country and region as passing months tragically render the evil, stupidity and selfishness of the US invasion clearly and without ambiguity or nuance.

See Full Review » (7 answers)
NT Rating: 3.5 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil reviewed this story - Dec 8, 2009
Phil's Rating
3.1

This would be quality journalism if it were the first in an investigative series. All it does is sit there and act scary. It really needs to suggest constructive means by which readers can follow up, especially to check on water quality in locations that are significant to them.

See Full Review » (6 answers)
NT Rating: 3.8 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil reviewed this story - Sep 20, 2009
Phil's Rating
3.7

Rich's point in writing about Glenn Beck is unclear. He seems to be suggesting that Beck is a sort of populist, voicing a sort of nonpartisan suspicion and frustration with politics in general in the U.S. I'm not sure that's what he's driving at, and if it is, he could make the point more clearly. Rich seems to be getting pithy when he contends that "[t]oo many Americans are impatiently waiting for results" of the administration's stimulus measures. But ar all these impatient ... More »

See Full Review » (6 answers)
NT Rating: 4.0 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil reviewed this story - Mar 12, 2009
Phil's Rating
5.0

This polling report provides food for constructive thought and debate. It recognizes several of the dimensions of the polling issue under discussion, including the important and interesting issue of age demographics as a differentiator with regard to the impact of "newsprint" news.

The main impact of the disappearance of local newspapers, I expect, will continue to be the growing vacuum of leadership in civic discourse. The Internet diffuses sources of information and opinion to the extent that it becomes easier and easier for a reader to allow him/herself exposure only to what matches his/her preferences or interests. This is true whether we're talking about "community calendar" type of reading, or editorial and opinion reading. The fact is that print ... More »

See Full Review » (7 answers)
NT Rating: 4.1 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil reviewed this story - Mar 12, 2009
Phil's Rating
2.3

The article lacks any claim to be more elevated than a random thought, and by no means an original one. (Perhaps the - unseen online - newsprint context in which it appeared in the CS Monitor might have lent it some pith.) It almost reads like Regan's own internal memo to CS Monitor management - "Hey, in case you haven't noticed, ink's not selling any more, even in pdf form. Can we please move into the second half of this decade now?" The Monitor's embrace of alternative journalism or whatever one calls it has been lukewarm at best, as though everyone was huddled in the nave of the Mother Church awaiting the second coming of Gutenberg.

See Full Review » (6 answers)
NT Rating: 3.1 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil reviewed this story - Jan 28, 2009
Phil's Rating
2.6

This opinion piece is a good example of a lack of sound editorial policy on the part of Arab News. Ramzy Baroud has little patience for what he has seen and heard of the new U.S. Administration's Israel/Gaza/West Bank initiatives and pronouncements. But he may not realize that his judgment is highly premature since U.S. policy in this regard always begins with strong public support for Israel during any conflict. Obama would have been naive indeed to have launched a new U.S. initiative in any other way. To have done so would have been to risk the perceptions of inconstancy and wavering in its commitment to the Jewish state, and so potentially to have further destabilized the current conflict in Gaza. What Mr. Baroud ... More »

I share in Mr. Baroud's disappointment that the new U.S. administration seems to be in a great hurry to bring stale thinking to bear on Gaza and the West Bank. I hope soon to hear U.S. officials begin to talk intelligently about the handful of fairly concrete alternative proposals that have been put forward in the international community.

See Full Review » (7 answers)
NT Rating: 3.5 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil reviewed this story - Dec 18, 2008
Phil's Rating
4.4

It is a succinct, balanced, and fact-based article that sticks to its purpose: describing the gay community's [actually its leaders'] frustration with what appears to be a decision that may not have been well considered by Obama and his people.

I am quite puzzled why Obama would choose this way to reach across the divide on full citizenship for lgbt people. Surely there must be clergy who, say, oppose gay marriage but have not lumped lbgt people with child molesters. Surely Obama's people know that this sad stereotype is one of the most difficult lbgt battles for respect and understanding. I wish that lbgt leaders and others had responded to this decision by using it to question whether Obama, "fierce advocate" though he ... More »

See Full Review » (7 answers)
NT Rating: 3.6 | See All NT Reviews »
Phil reviewed this story - Dec 15, 2008
Phil's Rating
2.9

This piece presents a sweeping generalization -- that life in Cuba is at least as miserable as it was before Castro -- but provides only anecdotal evidence that this is the case. Facts and statistics presented do a good job of quantifying Cuba's current day status vis a vis other nations in the Americas, presenting a mixed picture. But the gist of the article is clearly pessimistic ("por que?") and one would hope the writer would have some sounder socio-historical evidence to support that view. It's a very brief article to make such a bold point, and unfortunately does not support its thesis convicingly. (As much as anything, it feeds on and reinforces the negative expectations of US readers with regard to the Cuban economy.)

In my view the Castros and the Cuban "revolution" are dead letters with regard to US journalistic criticism. I would like to see more constructive feature journalism on the prospects for improved US-Cuban relations as Raul succeeds Fidel, Fidel fades away, and global economic reality sets in. Will Raul be a western Mugabe? No? Will he be Fidel? No? Will he survive in power? Why? What other possibilities might arise? Instead Robles treats us to an unedifying account of Cubans ... More »

See Full Review » (7 answers)
NT Rating: 3.1 | See All NT Reviews »
(Beta)

Levels & Stats

Member LevelHelp
2.9 avg.
2.9 avg.
Activity
2.2 avg.
Experience
4.0 avg.
Ratings
4.5 avg.
Transparency
1.4 avg.
Validation
3.0 avg.

StatsHelp
Reviews
12
Answers
61
Comments
0
Ratings Received
2
Number of Raters
2
Ratings Given
0

Member Ratings

Ratings received by Phil (2) Help



Ratings given by Phil Help

No ratings given yet.

Phil's Widget

Add this widget to your site »