Naomi Isler

Founding Member (since April 2006)
Help

I have never been a journalist. However, at various times I have been in a position to know the 'true facts' of a newsworthy situation. I then watched both the newsmaker spin on and the media interpretations (for the lack of a better word) of those facts. Different planets, on too many occasions.

About Naomi Help
Occupation: retired
Favorites Help
Topics: World, U.S.
Contact Info Help
Email:
Last Visit: Oct 2, 2011 - 3:39 PM PDT
Last Edit: Apr 11, 2008 - 5:53 PM PDT

This profile can be seen by everyone, including search engines. Help
| Network | |

Activity

Show all | Reviews | Posts | Starred | Comments
Naomi reviewed this story - Aug 8, 2011
Naomi's Rating
3.0

Rating Agencies - hmmmm. Aren't they the same people who decided that mortgage backed securities were AAA???

See Full Review » (2 answers)
NT Rating: 3.0 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi commented on this review – Jul. 25, 2011
Naomi Isler
4.2
(NT Rating: 4.4)
Reviewed by Naomi Isler - Jul. 25, 2011

The story seems based in factual material, but also has a lot of opinion-based-on-fact. And the historical examples of Muslims in Europe are really outdated - the Ottomans were pretty defunct befiore WW I. Part of the problem is that most European national states feel themselves to at least be Christian based (note the number of "Christian Democratic" parties), and of one only major ethnicity. Muslim immigration disturbs this image, especially when first generation immigrants tend to be old country traditionalists (as all immuigrant groups tend to be). And job and education discrimination against these populations is rampant. Well,that paragraph is really a comment - sorry.

Naomi Isler Comment:

My other thought is that the response of the police should have heads rolling in Norway’s public safety departments – the response time to the island shootings and the excuses used are really outrageous.

Naomi reviewed this story - Jul 25, 2011
Naomi's Rating
4.2

The story seems based in factual material, but also has a lot of opinion-based-on-fact. And the historical examples of Muslims in Europe are really outdated - the Ottomans were pretty defunct befiore WW I. Part of the problem is that most European national states feel themselves to at least be Christian based (note the number of "Christian Democratic" parties), and of one only major ethnicity. Muslim immigration disturbs this image, especially when first generation immigrants tend to be old country traditionalists (as all immuigrant groups tend to be). And job and education discrimination against these populations is rampant. Well,that paragraph is really a comment - sorry.

See Full Review » (5 answers)
NT Rating: 4.4 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi posted this story - Jul 16, 2011
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Jul 4, 2011
Naomi's Rating
5.0

It's not read often enough.

See Full Review » (6 answers)
NT Rating: 5.0 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi posted this story - Jul 4, 2011
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Jul 3, 2011
Naomi commented on this story – Jul. 3, 2011

The issue is who is going to spend the money needed to hire the people needed to do the fact checking.

Naomi commented on this story – Jul. 1, 2011

Is there any (late) 20th century case law on this???

Naomi reviewed this story - Jun 27, 2011
Naomi's Rating
5.0

The story seems to be well researched and sourced, and is well written. However, it reminds me of the stories a few years ago about the VA's care and facilities, in patient and outpatient, for physically and psychologically wounded service people. Whether or not one considers the wars ill conceived and ill managed, the treatment of those fighting and of their families is outrageous.

See Full Review » (5 answers)
NT Rating: 4.6 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi commented on this story – Jun. 24, 2011

Can someone explain to me the real difference between what Obama is doing in Libya and what FDR did with Lend Lease?

Naomi reviewed this story - Jun 19, 2011
Naomi's Rating
3.9

The story consolidates reports from several locations, though it does not specifically source them. And it emphasizes that education is one of the areas cut due to budget shortfalls. Most interesting is the last paragraph, which does cite a source, and begs the question: if increased expenditures apparently didn't lead to gains in pupil achievement, what happened to 'no child left behind'?? (Results from 'race to the top' weren't available in 2008 because it didn't exist yet.

See Full Review » (6 answers)
NT Rating: 3.6 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi commented on this story – Jun. 12, 2011

There is nothing new about this information, and the author points to past efforts to correct the problem. But agribusiness always wins out.

Naomi reviewed this story - Jun 8, 2011
Naomi's Rating
3.3

It's ideologically driven, but is a good overview of the 'conservative' thought process on the economy, written by a well known right winger. Among other things, if fails to see replacing military hardware as simply stimulating military contractors as opposed to automobile manufacturers and ordinary citizens. It glides over the issue of who pays taxes, and then ignores the fact that part of Obama's deficit solution is bringing taxes back to pre Bush levels - when that revenue loss is one of the chief causes of the deficit - etc. etc.

See Full Review » (6 answers)
NT Rating: 3.1 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi reviewed this story - Jun 3, 2011
Naomi's Rating
4.2

It seems to report facts. However, I think actual quotations from the leaked cables would have made it much more useful. Or do we have to buy The Nation to get them? (My score is predicated on the idea that even without the quotes this is useful knowledge).

See Full Review » (4 answers)
NT Rating: 4.3 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - May 30, 2011
Naomi's Rating
4.4

I don't think this needs comment

See Full Review » (4 answers)
NT Rating: 4.3 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi reviewed this story - May 29, 2011
Naomi's Rating
3.7

It's insightful, informative, and much too short. It really should have additional detail, or show the table cited, or something to support its conclusions. Thgis almost looks like a preview or a longer article.

See Full Review » (6 answers)
NT Rating: 3.7 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - May 29, 2011
Naomi commented on this story – May. 26, 2011

Excuse me again – 43 + 9 is actually 52. I used to be able to add.

Naomi commented on this story – May. 26, 2011

Excuse me, but 43% + 9% = 51%. In other words, the people who like the medicare plan still win, if they can just stop carving each other up,..

Naomi commented on this story – May. 25, 2011

It would be useful to see what legal protests are being undertaken. I believe the Supreme Court has upheld one state’s requirement for a photo id, but am not sure where ‘more restrictive’ laws are in the court system now. Also, where are things like the Florida ... More »

Naomi reviewed this story - May 25, 2011
Naomi's Rating
4.0

Unfortunately,m though it should be read, it's not very good journalism. It speaks about the statistical insignificance of voter fraud, and the way the issue is being abused. However, it gives almost no specifics on the proposed law's requirements - which purports to be the article's subject. .

See Full Review » (4 answers)
NT Rating: 3.4 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi reviewed this story - May 23, 2011
Naomi's Rating
4.0

It's a good, well written piece. It's main focus is the strategy and tactics of not only exposing Fox News well known biases, but of trying to build up a progressive alternative. It goes into issues of relationship of this effort to the Democrati party and presidential establishment. And that's where the question is - the article requires thinking about whether it's enough to just 'fight the right' but whether a viable alternative needs to be offered.

See Full Review » (4 answers)
NT Rating: 3.9 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi reviewed this story - May 5, 2011
Naomi's Rating
4.0

The story seems to be based on statements of a couple of intelligence chiefs, neither of whom probably feels free in revealing 'the whole truth and nothing but the truth'. And come on - were they really supposed to take an embedded video photographer in with them?

See Full Review » (4 answers)
NT Rating: 3.4 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi commented on this story – May. 3, 2011

China and Thailand??? Especially Thailand, which almost had a civil war recently, and may yet? China, which has done little infrastructure investment and hasn’t yet discovered quality control? Not sure about this.

Naomi reviewed this story - Apr 29, 2011
Naomi's Rating
4.0

Well, it's journalism based on statistics, but are the statistics verifiable? And even small percentages of something 'worldwide' will turn out to be pretty big.

So why is almost everything I buy made in China?

See Full Review » (5 answers)
NT Rating: 3.9 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi commented on this review – Apr. 26, 2011
Lynn Caporale
4.5
(NT Rating: 4.2)
Reviewed by Lynn Caporale - Apr. 28, 2011

This report comes at a time when the problem is clearly apparent (water restrictions have been imposed for the first time) but without waiting until the disaster stage (reservoirs completely dry) to present 1) a clear review of the current situation, 2) faulty assumptions that have led to this point and 3) possible (expensive) remedies. I would like to know more about what, if anything, the state government is planning to address the issue (other than Governor Perry's urging people to pray for rain this weekend).

This is a nationwide problem that demands more attention. People have been too casual about the availability of clean water, allowing development (e.g. Southern California vs.the Colorado River) and industry (e.g. hydraulic fracturing) that puts future inexpensive availability of potable water at risk.

water-intensive drilling technique, hydraulic fracturing, could capture a significant part of the reserves. In isolated places around the region, leaks from old oil wells ... More »

Naomi Isler Comment:

I’m in 200 per cent agreement with Lynn Caporale’s review. As she notes, Texas is not the only place where future water supply is going to be a problem. Overdevelopment, trying to make semi arid areas look like Connecticut, overintensive farming practices – there ... More »

Naomi commented on this story – Apr. 25, 2011

I seem to remember that Bill O’Reilly recently (according to Jon Stewart) stated that the idea Obama was not born in the US was false (along with a few other falsities. And what the birthers don’t seem to realize is that they are indicting John McCain and the Republican ... More »

Naomi commented on this story – Apr. 23, 2011

Would it not have made more sense to post the actual WSJ article?

Naomi commented on this story – Apr. 13, 2011

Am I wrong about the fact that a child of a U.S. citizen who is born abroad is automatically a U.S. citizen? If I am wrong, what would be the citizenship of children born to U.S. diplomats on overseas posting, foreign correspondents of U.S. newspapers, businesspeople in overseas ... More »

Naomi reviewed this story - Apr 13, 2011
Naomi's Rating
4.0

The brief article and the video are basically quite accurate. However, they are not exactly news. These problems, though not the new scientific measurements, have been around and known for years; they just aren't sexy enough to make headlines. And debates in DC over farm policy make everyone's eyes glaze over - except for agribusiness's.

See Full Review » (4 answers)
NT Rating: 3.7 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi commented on this story – Apr. 11, 2011

How does this explain the victory of the conservative Wisconsin Supreme Court (Chief?) Justice who will presumably vote to uphold Governor Walker’s action?

Naomi commented on this review – Apr. 8, 2011
Megan Doe
4.0
(NT Rating: 3.2)
Reviewed by Megan Doe - Apr. 8, 2011

I thought this was an awesome idea! Not only are they cleaning up the environment, they are also building schools in Guatemala.

Naomi Isler Comment:

A very clever,creative, economical idea. And pardon me for being a cynic, but do they have either earthquakes or hurricanes in that area?

Naomi commented on this story – Apr. 8, 2011

Can we think of this as a story about privatization? And in terms of China’s overall medical services, I wonder about our own underserved populations – would conditions in some Indian reservations or depopulating rural areas, or states with terrible medicaid programs be ... More »

Naomi commented on this story – Apr. 5, 2011

What’s missing in all the Medicaid debate is (a) some analysis of the productivity lost when poorer people, who probably have jobs without health benefits, can’t get health problems addressed and (b) some indication of what savings could be achieved by morphing from a pay ... More »

Naomi commented on this story – Mar. 31, 2011

OK, I’m a cynic. But while I recognize the incredible short term damage they will do between now and 2012, I would like to think that they will alienate enough ‘moderates’ to produce Democratic majorities again?? Which I optimistically assume will mean somewhat ... More »

Naomi commented on this story – Mar. 31, 2011

Why not add Zimbabwe to the list of governments we should go after?
Or, maybe in some far off time in some far off galaxy there will be some galactic wide power to stop murderous governments (I’m sure the Wampanogs, Cherokees, Sioux, Apache, etc. would have ... More »

Naomi commented on this story – Mar. 22, 2011

One thing has troubled me. I know that Egypt just had its ‘revolution’ and that its army is trying to run the country. But they are right next door, and we’ve been arming them for years – is there no way they could have, in some kind of pan Arab solidarity, ... More »

Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Feb 9, 2011
Naomi's Rating
4.0

This is a guarded, but apparently factual account of an AP investigation into the CIA's mishandling of some cases. While it tries to be circumspect, the people involved could probably be identified. Given the highly secretive nature of the agency it's interesting that AP found people willing to discuss this. It looks like the kind of story that 'media' are often accused of not doing.

See Full Review » (4 answers)
NT Rating: 3.9 | See All NT Reviews »
Naomi posted and reviewed this story - Feb 8, 2011
(Beta)

Levels & Stats

Member LevelHelp
3.3 avg.
3.3 avg.
Activity
5.0 avg.
Experience
3.1 avg.
Ratings
3.8 avg.
Transparency
1.9 avg.
Validation
3.0 avg.

StatsHelp
Reviews
545
Answers
2,863
Comments
97
Ratings Received
238
Number of Raters
60
Ratings Given
1

Naomi's Widget

Add this widget to your site »